Aldi appeal - public inquiry List of core documents for the Aldi appeal public inquiry Appeal inquiry timetable (version 2) CD1 November 2021 planning application drawings and amended plans CD1.1 Site Location Plan CD1.2 Initially Submitted Application Plans CD1.3 May 2022 Updated Application Plans CD1.4 Refused Application Plans CD1.5 Updated Landscape Plan (Ref: 17154 L01 Rev B) CD2 November 2021 planning application supporting documents and relevant correspondence CD2.1 Connect Transport Assessment Scoping Note dated 19 April 2021 CD2.2 SCC Highways Pre-Application Response dated 17 June 2021 CD2.3 EBC Pre-application Response (Ref: 2021/2761) CD2.4 Email from EBC received 23 September 2021 confirming pre-application response from the conservation officer CD2.5 Email from EBC received 19 October 2021 confirming scope for sequential assessment CD2.6 Planning, Retail and Economic Statement (‘PRES’), (Nov 2021), Planning Potential CD2.7 Design and Access Statement (DAS) (Oct 2021), The Harris Partnership CD2.8 Transport Assessment (‘TA’) (Nov 2021), Connect Consultants CD2.9 Travel Plan (Nov 2021), Connect Consultants CD2.10 Ecological Assessment (Oct 2021), Ecology Solutions CD2.11 Daylight and Sunlight Assessment (Oct 2021), Herrington Consulting Limited Assess 1 of 2 | Assess 2 of 2 CD2.12 Renewable & Low Carbon Energy Statement (Oct 2021), Sol Environment CD2.13 Flood Risk Assessment and Sustainable Drainage Strategy (Apr 2022), Stirling Maynard Consulting Engineers CD2.14 Heritage Assessment (Oct 2021), Cogent Heritage CD2.15 Environmental Noise Report (Oct 2021), Sharps Redmore Acoustic Consultants CD2.16 Statement of Community Involvement (Oct 2021), becg CD2.17 Desk Study and Geo-environmental Assessment Report (Sep 2021), Brownfield Solutions Ltd Study 1 of 2 | Study 2 of 2 CD2.18 Arboricultural Assessment and Method Statement and Tree Protection Plan (Oct 2021), Barrell Tree Consultancy CD2.19 Connect TN02 – Servicing Route Assessment dated 02 February 2022 CD2.20 Connect TN03 Parking Stress Assessment dated 14 March CD2.21 Connect TN04 – Response to LHA Comments (Travel Plan) CD2.22 Connect Technical Note TN05 – Response to LHA Comments (Access) dated 03 May 2022 CD2.23 PP Comprehensive Response Letter to Officers dated 31 May 2022 CD2.24 PP Letter Response to Committee Report dated 12 August 2022 CD3 November 2021 planning application consultation responses and third party comments and committee report CD3.1 2021/3857 EBC Decision Notice dated 19 August 2022 CD3.2 2021/3857 EBC August 2022 Committee Report CD3.3 2021/3857 EBC August 2022 Formal Committee Minutes CD3.4 August 2022 Committee Transcript CD3.5 Environmental Services (Pollution) Consultation Response dated 12 January 2022 CD3.6 SCC Highways Consultation Response dated 24 December 2021 CD3.7 Design and Conservation Officer Consultation Response dated 07 February 2022 CD3.8 Thames Ditton and Giggs Hill Green Conservation Area Advisory Committee (‘CAAC’) Response dated 17 January 2022 CD3.9 SCC Highways Consultation Response (no objection) dated 17 May 2022 CD3.10 Email from EBC requesting further justification on retail matters dated 24 May 2022 CD3.11 Copy of all other Consultation Responses CD3.12 Email from Officers confirming recommendation for approval dated 02 August 2022 CD3.13 2021/3857 EBC Committee Update Sheet published on 12 August 2022 CD3.14 MRPP Objection on behalf of Tesco dated 12 August 2022 CD4 Planning policy documents CD4.1 Elmbridge Borough Core Strategy (2011) CD4.2 Elmbridge Borough Development Management Plan (2015) CD4.3 National Model Design Code (2021) CD4.4 Elmbridge Borough Emerging Local Plan (Regulation 19 Draft) (March 2022) CD4.5 Elmbridge Borough Design and character SPD (2012) CD4.6 Design and Character Companion Guide: Thames Ditton, Long Ditton, Hinchley Wood & Weston Green (April 2012) CD4.7 Elmbridge Borough Flood risk SPD (2016) CD4.8 Elmbridge Borough Parking SPD (2020) CD4.9 Elmbridge Borough Development Contributions SPD (2021) CD4.10 Giggs Hill Green Conservation Area Statement of Designation (Dated March 2013) CD4.11 Thames Ditton and Giggs Hill Green Conservation Area Character Appraisal & Management Proposals (October 2009) CD4.12 Surrey County Council Vehicular, Cycle and Electric Vehicle Parking Guidance for New Development (February 2023) CD4.13 Elmbridge Retail Assessment (2016) Retail 1 of 3 | Retail 2 of 3 | Retail 3 of 3 CD4.14 Historic England’s Historic Environment Good Practice Advice in Planning Note 3: The Setting of Heritage Assets (GPA 3) (2017) CD4.15 Historic England’s Managing Significance in Decision-Taking in the Historic Environment (2015) CD4.16 Historic England’s Advice Note 1: Conservation Area Appraisal, Designation and Management CD4.17 Historic England’s Advice Note 12: Statements of Heritage Significance CD4.18 Historic England’s Conservation Principles, Policies and Guidance CD4.19 Elmbridge Local Cycling and Walking Infrastructure Plan CD4.20 Elmbridge Borough Establishing Local Housing Need (2022) CD4.21 Elmbridge Borough List of Local Buildings of Special Architectural or Historic Interest CD4.22 Elmbridge Borough Assessment of Local Housing Needs (2020) CD4.23 Elmbridge Land Availability Assessment 2022 CD4.24 National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) 2021 (and associated National Planning Policy Guidance, as set out in the Statement of Common Ground) CD4.25 British Standard (BS) 4142:2014+A1:2019 Methods for rating and assessing industrial and commercial sound CD4.26 Noise Policy Statement for England (NPSE), March 2010 CD4.27 British Standard (BS) 8233:2014 CD4.28 World Health Organisation (WHO) Guidelines for Community Noise 2000 (GCN) CD4.29 World Health Organisation (WHO) Environmental Noise Guidelines for the European Region, 2018 CD4.30 British Standard (BS) 4142:1967 “Method of Rating Industrial Noise Affecting Mixed Residential and Industrial Area” CD4.31 British Standard (BS) 4142:1990 “Method for Rating industrial noise affecting mixed residential and industrial area” CD4.32 British Standard (BS) 4142:1997 “Method for Rating industrial noise affecting mixed residential and industrial area” CD4.33 Association of Noise Consultants (ANC) BS 4142:2014+A1:2019 Technical Note, March 2020 CD5 Appeal decisions and case law CD5.1 Tesco appeal Inspectors report (3789987) SOS Decision and Inspector’s Report, Milk Marketing Board site, Portsmouth Road APP/K3605/A/93/226167, APP/K3605/A/93/226166 CD5.2 Thames Ditton Youth Centre (2002/0924) CD5.3 Lidl Havering (App/B5480/W/22/3295360) CD5.4 Barnwell Manor Wind Energy Ltd v East Northamptonshire District and ors [2013] EWCA Civ 137 CD5.5 City & Country Bramshill Ltd v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2021] EWCA Civ 320 CD5.6 Catesby Estates Ltd v Steer [2018] EWCA Civ 1697 CD5.7 West Oxfordshire DC v Secretary of State and Rosconn Strategic Land Ltd [2018] EWHC 3065 (Admin) CD5.8 HFS Developments 2 Limited, (APP/H5390/V/21/3277137) CD6 Appeal documents – appellant CD6.1 Appellants Statement of Case CD6.1 Appx 1 | CD6.1 Appx 2 | CD6.1 Appx 3 | CD6.1 Appx 4 | CD6.1 Appx 5 | CD6.1 Appx 6 CD6.2 Additional Plans submitted with Appeal CD6.3 Statement of Common Ground CD6.4 Design Proof of Evidence (Tanya McLeod) CD6.4 Appx 1-3 | CD6.4 Appx 4-5 | CD6.4 Appx 6-9 CD6.5 Planning & Retail Proof of Evidence (Alastair Close) CD6.5 Planning & Retail Proof of Evidence - Appx 1 CD6.6 Transport Proof of Evidence (Colin White) Transport 1 of 2 | Transport 2 of 2 CD6.7 Heritage Proof of Evidence (Ignus Froneman) CD6.8 Noise Proof of Evidence (Keith Metcalfe) CD6.8 Noise Proof of Evidence - Appx 1 CD6.8 Noise Proof of Evidence - Summary CD6.9 Agreed Conditions CD6.10 Appellant Design Rebuttal (Tanya McLeod) CD6.11 Appellant Planning Rebuttal (Alastair Close) CD6.12 Appellant Noise Rebuttal (Keith Metcalfe) CD6.13 Appellant Highways Rebuttal CD7 Appeal documents – Elmbridge Borough Council CD7.1 Elmbridge Borough Council Statement of Case CD7.1 Appx 1a | CD7.1 Appx 1b | CD7.1 Appx 1c | CD7.1 Appx 1d | CD7.1 Appx 2 | CD7.1 Appx 3-5 CD7.2 EBC Noise Proof of Evidence (Reuben Peckham) CD7.3 EBC Heritage Proof of Evidence (Jason Clemons) CD7.4 EBC Planning Proof of Evidence (Carol Ann O’Kane) LPA Proof 1 of 4 | LPA Proof 2 of 4 | LPA Proof 3 of 4 | LPA Proof 4 of 4 | LPA Summary Proof of Evidence CD7.5 EBC Noise Rebuttal (Reuben Peckham) CD7.6 EBC Planning Rebuttal (Carol Ann O’Kane) CD8 Appeal documents – rule 6 CD8.1 Thames Ditton and Weston Green Residents’ Association Statement of Case CD8.1 Rule 6 Party - All Appendices CD8.2 Highways / Parking Proof of Evidence (Adrian Corcoran) CD8.3 General Matters Proof of Evidence (Karen Randolph) CD8.4 Design and Heritage Proof of Evidence (Michael Phillips) MBP's Appx 6 | MBP's Appx 7 CD9 Other documents CD9.1 DETR, “By Design: Urban design in the planning system: towards better practice” (Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment) CD9.2 National Design Guide CD9.3 National Model Design Code CD9.4 Lambeth Council Parking Guidance CD9.5 Living with Beauty: Report of the Building Better, Building Beautiful Commission CD9.6 Minutes of CAAC Meeting 7 September 2022 CD9.7 High Hedges Part 8 Anti-social Behaviour Act 2003 Date published: 09 June 2023 Categories: Referenced Next article